Members, Sign In. Not a member? Sign Up

Ultimate Rollercoaster > Discussion Forums > Roller Coasters, Parks & Attractions > Pennsylvania's Picnic Groves and Trolley Parks

Pennsylvania's Picnic Groves and Trolley Parks


2/6/13 at
2:43:47 PM

Phil Gould has put together a TR from a couple of his recent road trips in the USA for my website themagiceye.

It's a long TR so I'd like to share just one section of it (A UK perspective on US Parks) with the posters on URC

Here we go then.This part concentrates on Idlewild


Situated in the Laurel Highlands near the town of Ligonier (which looks like the hometown of Marty Mcfly out of Back To The Future).

It was set up in 1878 and is the third oldest operating amusement park in the United States.

A sister park to Kennywood it was also operated by the same family until being sold at the end of 2007.

Rides sit alongside Picnic Groves, Storybook Forest and the rather strange but wonderful attraction that is Mister Rogers' Neighbourhood.

Driving around 50 miles to the east of downtown Pittsburgh, with a slight detour to go and visit the Frank Lloyd Wright masterpiece Fallingwater, I found myself on the Lincoln Highway in the middle of rural Pennsylvania.

Not the most obvious place for an amusement park but this is where I found the truly enchanting Idlewild.

A park that is set in the middle of a heavily wooded area.

From the road you can see some of the picnic groves and nursery rhyme buildings. But most of the park is shielded by the trees so you can't see what is on offer until you are actually walking among its many attractions.

The place is divided by Loyalhanna Creek which has tended to make a nuisance of itself from time to time by flooding.

It is divided into themed areas - Storybook Forest, Raccoon Lagoon, Mister Rogers Neighbourhood, Hootin' Holler, Olde Idlewild, Jumpin Jungle (an overgrown play area) and the ubiquitous water park Soak Zone.

Although each area has its own character they tended to blend into one another because of the nature of the park.

Some of these sections while not being exactly historic are probably worth a mention because of their quirkiness.

I will start off my tour in Olde Idlewild which is home to many of the traditional amusement rides and probably the nearest Idlewild gets to having a midway.

On what was originally a large lawn I found a number of rides including the Spider, an octopus ride with two cars per arm, this was new to Kennywood in 1979 but moved to Idlewild in 1991, and a 16 car Eli Bridge Ferris Wheel.

Just below these were a set of Dodgems. The building dates back to 1931 but the cars themselves were of a more recent vintage.

Just eight years later the park added its current Whip ride which had replaced an earlier travelling version.

This open topped version manufactured by W F Mangels has 12 cars - not the originals as they were ruined when the Loyalhanna once burst its banks.

Also in this area are the Lifting Paratrooper dating back to 1969, Tilt-A-Whirl transferred from Kennywood in 1989 and replacing an earlier model and the Super Round Up.

Moving along the midway I came to one very rare ride indeed The Caterpillar.

Manufactured in 1947 by Allan Herschell this is one of the few rides of its type still operating complete with a canvas cover.

Just peaking out of the tree tops behind this ride I spotted a unique attraction that was very familiar to me.

The Wild Mouse.

This was built by Vekoma for the Prater in Vienna in1985.

Two years later it was bought by Alton Towers in North Staffordshire. I remember going on the ride and thinking it was pretty rough and it had very harsh braking too.

I didn't have chance to renew my acquaintance with the the ride as it wasn't operating on the day I visited Idlewild. I can't say I felt that upset.

I also understand that the ride hasn't operated at all in the 2012 season and its future might be in question.

Walking away from the creek I passed the 1977 Eli Bridge Scrambler and a more recent arrival the Flying Aces or Flying Skooters ride.

I also found the park's Carousel which was one of the last to be manufactured by the Philadelphia Toboggan Company in 1931.

It has 48 horses and two chariots on its spinning platform. The ride was the subject of major restoration in 1985 and has been designated an historic landmark.

Alongside this and heading off into the woods was the junior wooden coaster the Rollo Coaster. Also built by the Philadelphia Toboggan company in 1938 this ride uses the park's terrain to create a fun out and back ride.

Although it only has shallow hills it is still worth squeezing yourself into the train for a trip round the track. Most of the course of the coaster is hidden from view because of the dense trees that surround it.

Doubling back on myself I found Hootin' Holler.

This was built in 1976 to commemorate the US Bicentennial and modelled on a typical 19th century Western town.

There is a log flume and two unusual attractions. Dizzy Lizzy's Four Quarters Saloon - a haunted swing attraction which wasn't operating on the day I visited and Confusion Hill.

The latter is a walk through attraction and uses optical illusions to confound and confuse guests during their guided tour.

Visitors are spun a yarn by their guide about how the hotel came to be in the state it is in before witnessing such things as water running uphill, walking through a titled room and sitting on a chair halfway up a wall.

I then followed the path back down to the creek and walked across a wooden bridge to find myself in Raccoon Lagoon.

This is the children's section of the park and replaced Kiddieland when the Wild Mouse was constructed on that attraction's site. Although it has moved across the creek it still contains many of the vintage attractions from the defunct section of the park.

It covers eight acres and many of the attractions are hidden among the trees. Rides included are The Turtle which first took children for a spin around its shallow undulating track in 1956, miniature ferris wheel dating back to 1955, the hand carts from 1954 and the Streetcar from a year later that still takes youngsters for a nostalgic trip.

They have been joined by more recent arrivals including the Red Baron and mini Dodgems.

Also on the south side of the creek is a truly unique attraction Mister Rogers' Neighbourhood.

Opening in 1989 this was based on an American television show which was aimed at pre school children.

It was the brainchild of Fred Rogers who was born in nearby Latrobe and often visited Idlewild as a child.

The television show ran from 1968 to 2001. On the ride guests board a tram to be taken on a tour of the neighbourhood meeting all the regular characters that are still remembered by parents.

The ride used to end up with a singing and huggin' party at King Friday's Palace. Luckily for me the park has now dropped the insistence on huggin' as cuddling strangers isn't a very English thing to do.

To reach the final area of the park I headed back across the creek and away from the midway.

Here I came to something that used to operate as a separate attraction before is now incorporated into the main park - Storybook Forest.

In the 1950s Arthur Jennings worked as the clown Happy Dayze at Idlewild. He was also an accomplished engineer and approached the park's management about creating a nursery rhyme and fairy tale park which would be based on 'emotion rather than motion'.

He built many of the models himself and when it first opened for business in 1956 there were also live characters to greet visitors.

During the 50s - known as the baby boomer years in the States - many similar road side attractions sprung up.

But finding a storybook land these days is increasingly rare. It was fascinating to wander round such a historic piece of amusement park history.

I entered the Forest through a large book which started with the legend 'here is the land of once upon a time'.

Once inside the book I was greeted by Mother Goose. As this coincided with a passing rain storm (the only one during the entire trip) we got chatting and as soon as she discovered that I had come all the way from London she seemed very impressed that I had made the effort to visit Idlewild.

It turned out that her son was the park general manager and she gave me a potted history of the park which certainly helped pass a few minutes as the storm clouds retreated.

We were joined by Captain Candy who lives on the Good Ship Lollipop. He is very popular with young guests as he is a friendly pirate who hands out sweets.

After the Captain had returned to his ship Mother Goose informed me that it was very rare to have a lad acting as pirate as the part was usually played by a young girl.

But apparently this Captain had wanted to charter the Good Ship Lollipop since being a schoolboy. Once the sun had returned I set off around the path visiting such characters as Humpty Dumpty, Little Miss Muppet and Snow White.

When I met the Old Woman Who Lived In A Shoe and she found out I was from London she told me how her niece had moved to England to get married but had recently revealed she was getting divorced.

We spent a few minutes discussing the state of marriage as an institution in the UK. A topic I wasn't expecting to end up discussing in the land of happy ever after!

Story Book Forest was a great way to pass an hour and a suitable way to finish my day at Idlewild. Truly a fantastic park with many unique attractions.

I think I was lucky to visit on a quiet day as I understand the park can get very busy.

If you are going to visit Kennywood make sure you take a short detour to visit Idlewild too.

Full Article with Photos

Re: Pennsylvania's Picnic Groves and Trolley Parks by frontrow frontrow Profile at 2/6/13 3:20:08 PM
That was a really nice TR. I'm glad someone from the UK got to visit Idelwild. I live about 45 minutes from the park. Idelwild reminds me a lot of Knoebles. It has that type of natural setting. Years ago I would take my family to Idelwild every year, because it's a great kids park and admission was relatively cheap. Now my kids are older and the price of admission has greatly increased. Idelwild is the bone yard for rides that were once at Kennywood. With the exception of the 2 coasters, the carousel, and a few other rides, I can recall riding all the flats when they were at Kennywood. Idelwild is a small, unique park, but it doesn't have a major coaster. They have a Wild Mouse, and a classic JUNIOR wooden coaster. For years I have been waiting for at least a mid sized wooden coaster. It seems that's never going to happen. The park is set in a gorgeous part of PA. In fact I fly fish for trout in the same creek that runs through the park. I'm glad the author liked Idelwild, but I actually would not recommend this park to the average enthusiast, unless you are in the area. Without a major coaster, mostly standard flats, high admission, and usually large crowds, I feel the average enthusiast would be a little disappointed. It's been a few years since I've been to the park. We tend to spend our days at Kennywood. I'm curious to read other opinions about Idelwild.

I just finished reading the entire thing. The author really appreciates historical and rare rides. It seems to be his main focus, and what drew him to parks like Kennywood, Idelwild, Lakemont, Knoebles, etc. I am surprised that he didn't visit Hershey. The entire TR was very enjoyable to read, and has a very interesting perspective. Thanks for sharing. It's always nice to read someone's opinions about my home parks.

* This post was modified at 2/7/13 12:50:37 PM *

Re: Pennsylvania's Picnic Groves and Trolley Parks by d_n_s_u at 2/9/13 3:11:49 PM
Hi frontrow

Thanks for your comments - I will pass them onto Phil.

You were right about the focus of his visits - He said himself that he wanted to visit the old fashioned amusement parks that have survived into the 21st century rather than the major theme parks.

The second part of his "USA Odyssey" takes in New York State and will be up on themagiceye in about 2 months time.

Phil visited the following:

Coney Island,
Playland Rye
Midway State Park
Darien Lake
Ontario Beach
Herschell Carousel Factory Museum and
Sylvan Beach

I think I'm right in saying that Sylvan Beach was one of Phil's favourite parks he encountered on his 2 trips:

"..The Crazy Dazy teacup ride from Eldridge Park in Elmira was installed in 1987 but is much older.

I was surprised that this ride still has a bit of a kick as it spins and weaves its way around two turntables.

Next to this was one of the main reasons I had come to the park: The Tip Top Bounce.

Manufactured by Hrubetz there was only ever one example of this ride in the UK was being imported for the Festival of Britain in 1951.

When I first got to Sylvan Beach the ride wasn’t operating but I soon realised that one operator was responsible for this and the Crazy Dazy so operated them on a rota basis.

Before long the ride was running and to my absolute delight it still bounced.

What a completely fantastic ride!

I’m not sure who owns Sylvan Beach Amusement Park but they deserve a huge pat on the back for preserving this piece of Americana.."

Re: Pennsylvania's Picnic Groves and Trolley Parks by frontrow frontrow Profile at 2/9/13 4:02:50 PM
I actually tried to email him and tell him how much I liked his trip reports. For what ever reason, the email didn't go through. I can't wait to read more of his reports.
Re: Pennsylvania's Picnic Groves and Trolley Parks by mugen828 mugen828 Profile at 2/10/13 1:24:39 PM
It's awesome to read something like this. I loved how he described everything. It felt as if I was reading a TR from someone who actually writes books. Well done, and I'm glad there are people out there who appreciate the rides that are kept around for so long.
- mugen828
157 Coasters -- Favorite Coaster -- Nitro (SFGAdv)
117 Steel -- 40 Wood -- Home Park: SFGADv
Re: Pennsylvania's Picnic Groves and Trolley Parks by d_n_s_u at 2/10/13 1:59:42 PM
Hi mugen828

Thanks for your comments. I'll pass them onto Phil.

mugen828, frontrow, and anyone else who wishes to - you can email any comments to

if you want them printed at the end of the said article.

frontrow, Phil emailed me this morning and said he very much appreciated your comments.

Unfortunately time was against him in regards to visiting Hershey.

In regards to The Wild Mouse at Idlewild, I remember this having a "slanted" lifthill at Alton Towers UK (riders ended up leaning to the right as they climbed the lifthill) - Can anyone on these boards confirm as to whether the original plans for this ride had the whole lifthill enclosed in a tunnel with a revolving barrel effect to disorientate riders?

Not sure if this is a coaster myth or not. :-)



* This post was modified at 2/10/13 2:09:00 PM *